Welcome to Jimmy Hays Steak House
At Jimmy Hays Steak House, we offer a culinary experience steeped in tradition and warmth. Located in Island Park, NY, our steakhouse has been a beloved destination for 38 years, known for its elegant ambiance and impeccable service. Our menu features an array of expertly grilled steaks, complemented by delightful side dishes like creamed spinach and garlic mashed potatoes. Guests rave about our phenomenal service, with attentive staff ensuring an unforgettable dining experience. With options for everyone, including vegetarian dishes and a selection of fine wines, we create a welcoming atmosphere for families and groups alike. Come savor the essence of American steakhouse dining.
Jimmy Hays Steak House: Reviews & Ratings
Just got home from celebrating our 38th wedding anniversary here. Found out its been here for 38 yrs. The service from bus boy to our waitress were great and friendly. And Mike who I assume is the manager goes and checks on the tables. I ...
Nice elegant steak house. The tables are not on top of each other, so youre not crowded. The special was filet mignon on the bone with lobster chunks and sauce. Very tasty. The lighting is a bit dim. I needed my phones flashlight to read the menu.
1423 I like coming here! Food was very good. Our server was super nice Jimmy. We had a party of 14 and everyone was happy!!
Can never go wrong at Jimmy Hays, No matter what steak you choose you cannot go wrong , every steak they make is absolutely amazing . The Gorgonzola bread is by far the best G bread out there. Side dishes are delicious as well, I recommend ...
We had the best experience here last nightDanielle was our waitress and both my husband and I agree she was phenomenal! The best service weve had at a restaurant in a long, long time. The food was fantastic and the atmosphere was great, as well. Thanks for a great nightwell be back!
Food was great. I dropped a 100 bill on the floor when paying the check. Bill was returning to me in the lobby while waiting for coatcheck. Had no Idea. Kudos to the very honest staff.
The place can get loud and if your going for quiet conversation its not the place. The Cesar salad was well done and added anchovies were a bonus. My dry aged rib steak was very big 22 oz and well prepared. The Brussel sprouts and home ...
THE BEST IN LONG ISLAND!!!!!! Ive been coming here with my family for around 20 years now! The staff is like family, the food is angelic, the ambiance is perfect! You could not ask for a better steak house! 1000000010 will come back here until the day I die
Location
-
4310 Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY 11558 Hotline: (516) 432-5155
Welcome to Jimmy Hays Steak House: a culinary gem located at 4310 Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY. A haven for steak lovers, this elegant establishment has been serving satisfied patrons for over 38 years and continues to set the standard for American steakhouses.
The ambiance is a blend of classy and comfortable. With moderate noise, dressy decor, and ample seating arrangements that give diners the space they need, Jimmy Hays creates an inviting setting for any occasion. Whether you're celebrating a special anniversary like Saul Roth or simply enjoying a night out with family and friends, every visit is sure to be memorable.
What's on the Menu?
- Steaks: Each cut, from the juicy filet mignon to the ribeye, is prepped to perfection, delighting the taste buds of every meat enthusiast.
- Side Dishes: Accompany your steak with delicious options like garlic mashed potatoes, creamed spinach, and the crowd-favorite homemade tater tots.
- Signature Dishes: Don't miss out on the Lobster Fritters or the fragrant Fall Pumpkin Soup, which add a sophisticated twist to an already diverse menu.
But it's not just the food that shines here. Patrons rave about the exceptional service, often highlighting the attentiveness and friendliness of the staff. Danielle and the rest of the team know how to make each guest feel special, enhancing your dining experience. Martin G. Miller appreciated the non-crowded seating that afforded him the luxury of savoring his meal comfortably under dim, romantic lighting.
For those looking to unwind, the steak house offers a full bar featuring a range of beers, including Budweiser, Heineken, and Guinness. And if you're visiting during Happy Hour, you're in for a treat with various specials.
At Jimmy Hays Steak House, birthdays, anniversaries, or casual dinners take on new significance. It's not just about the incredible food; it's about the memories you create there. The complimentary elements, including outdoor seating, wheelchair access, and accommodating staff, make this an ideal destination for families and groups alike. Plus, with vegetarian options available, everyone is sure to find something delightful.
So why wait? Plan your visit to this Island Park institution today; a taste of perfection awaits at Jimmy Hays Steak House!
Contact Information:
Phone: (516) 432-5155
